Movie. Million Dollar Baby, 2004.

Posted by T on August 22, 2006
By Title, Movies

Apparently about a girl that wants to become a boxer, the movie is actually not about boxing, let alone female boxing.  The film raises the question, can the desire to end one’s life ever be justified or at least understood.

In other words, it is about euthanasia, a word coined from the Greek for “good death” or “pleasant death,” but which actually is a euphemism for murder, or self-murder, justified by criteria supplied by a society so addicted to its god of pleasure and pride that, when that god fails, the universe should properly end.

Eastwood attempts to elevate the film to the status of a true ethical dilemma by having his character visit a priest periodically to discuss deep issues. However, these discussions miscarry. The message, also consistent with the conceit of our age, seems to be that the mere raising of “deep” questions is a sign of spirituality. But those of us that have followed the career of Woody Allen have seen through the sham of that. Always learning, never knowing.

For plotting, pacing, and structure this movie is excellent, possibly Clint Eastwood’s best.

It is, I submit, objectively painful to see females boxing. One can imagine worse things, but one has to strain. How about: a girl wearing heavy boots and heaving a live grenade into a foxhole while being torn up by machine gun bullets.

But why subject ourselves to such images?

Perhaps the grotesqueness of the image is a metaphor for the theme the movie wants to bring home: fight and win, or die. That’s what life is. Nurturing is another illusion for the self-deceived.

That’s what life without God is in fact. I don’t recommend wallowing in it.



2 Comments to Movie. Million Dollar Baby, 2004.

  • Clint’s new movie, Iwo Jima, looks like a real winner also. The cinematography looks spectacular! And I heard he is making 2 versions of the movie, one from the US and the other from the Japanese perspective. If that is true, I love the idea, it’s brilliant!

  • We HATED this movie. After it came out, my students were buzzing about it for a while, so we watched it to see what they were talking about. We had a good discussion about it one day in class (Spanish class, but oh, well.), and I was surprised that the kids felt very strongly that the guy did the right thing at the end. I suggested that it would have been better if they had just let her die outright instead of going to crazy lengths to keep her alive. Not sure that was better, but at least it’s not murder. I think.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *